AMITBE said:
The reason is, the forum is not a place for learning as it once was.
Anyone serious about trading their hard earned money need to invest in learning at least some basics of the market, TA, FA etc.
I'm a student and a learner, and at this point this forum is not answering my needs.
Perhaps some debate could evolve on these issues.
Thank you all for all the learning and sharing.
HI to all Forum Members and especially to Amit
This is a serious point raised above.If forum degenerates in to another tip giving site(earlier in some post Aimt had hinted at "one line wonders") then the essence of forum is gone. Its not about trading or investing but sharing their knowledge and learning to share with others. Those who think it is a successful site for tips aresadly mistaken. The site has been enriched by the efforts of many knowledgeable members such as Saint, Amitbe, Satya,Murthy,Supratik, joy, amitkr and many more. Others also would have gained knowledge and invested wisely due to this forum. If they are in distress, help is available at hand. but this should not become run of the mill tip giving site. I fully share the anguish of Amit that it is not answering this need.
Personally , I always used to read at least a few threads for two reasons:
1. To understand the ways of Market , how it is reflecting the growth of Indian Economy and to what extent.
2. To understand the bright side of Human nature of being social and rational aminal take joy and pride in sharing and caring for each other even when one doesn't see other members in flesh and blood.
For me knowledge is more important and an end in itself and it should make a person better human being. Other things are incidental and consequntial.
Somewhere I gave analogy of Theoretical class and Laboratory class. This particula thread along with Teach a man to fish.. by Saint is to be treated as pure knoweldge thread. For Applied aspect there are other threads Some Good steals, Intermediate uptrend.., Supratik,s thread.
Inevitably , the urge to make money has spawned various coaching classes( One liners) but then as Leibniz would say this is not a perfect world but best of all compossible world. This is what makes it interesting as it always prompts us to evolve for betterment. Some byproducts are to be ignored.
Web is mostly open and attracts multitude of personalities. To filter some would be a mammoth task. So where ever you will go same thing may happen amit. Let us not be discouraged by this.
When market is at an interesting point there is all the more need for your analysis to understand its dynamics. If it saves a few so be it but a record is created which could be used in still better ways.
As always, it is entirely you decision and I respect it. Wish you all the best in all your endeavour.
with regards
Pankaj