Point one: @Dan every trader has his own set of his ta tools.
Point two: If you are comfortable on shorter tf of 5 min its good enough.
Point three: My disagreement was on the point that you give your 5 min tf trend line to justify a positional call given by the predictor. Let him use whatever ta he has chosen for giving this call and whether he discloses his studies or not.
Point four: But giving a positional call like this requires more than what you have commented.
@Ashu1234.
Point one: Agree with you that there are many sets of TA tools.
Point two: Do not know where you have that from, as I not have mentioned any words about any TF I feel comfortable with. I have mentioned the 5 min TF and the long term TF and nothing more and nothing less. So you can delete that point.
Point three: I have very well explained that giving a call, like the one mentioned from PR, can be easily spotted on the 5 min time frame. And the way I mentioned (5 times hitting a resistance line), is no shame to do that. Indeed, I told that this is a very good take to even take a trade against the long up trend. And I also told that there is still some room to the down side and we first have to see if the bigger up trend from the longer TF is broken.
Point four: Absolutely wrong. No agreement with you on that in that specific case, as long as it is not proved in other ways from PR. But from my side no need of that. If the coming calls are based on such strong patterns like the one today, so what? Lets move on and wait what is posted as next call. If PR improved the way he shows now, then I only can say: Well done.
Good trading / DanPickUp