Confused - Sharekhan vs Icicidirect vs Hdfc vs Kotak vs Indiabulls vs 5paise

[wasim_1ahmed]

hi i loved the information regarding online trading-wasim

 

[Satish_CN]

The Religare rep came canvassing yesterday. The picture was all rosy
You get interest of 3.5% (PA of course) on the balance with them.
The brokerage is .25% and .025% each leg for an adjustible deposit of Rs 2500; and lesser for bigger deposits.
exe based charting with the Pro, ODIN with Lite; The demo was real-time and fast, but the intraday charting was only Line (no OHLC or Candlestick); pl correct me if they offer it for intraday, as neither the rep nor his boss were able to confirm it.

Two Qns

1) Has anyone had any problems with Religare?

2) Is it true that IL&FS offers 0.02% single leg brokerage? If so the details please.

s

 

[lazytrader]

The Religare rep came canvassing yesterday. The picture was all rosy
You get interest of 3.5% (PA of course) on the balance with them.
The brokerage is .25% and .025% each leg for an adjustible deposit of Rs 2500; and lesser for bigger deposits.
exe based charting with the Pro, ODIN with Lite; The demo was real-time and fast, but the intraday charting was only Line (no OHLC or Candlestick); pl correct me if they offer it for intraday, as neither the rep nor his boss were able to confirm it.

Two Qns

1) Has anyone had any problems with Religare?

2) Is it true that IL&FS offers 0.02% single leg brokerage? If so the details please.

s

what do you mean by deposit? will it be refunded or is it plan charges? I am thinking of switching broker too. Here is a thread you might find useful.

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/29178-differences-between-trader-terminals.html

I have pasted some links to PIB, TT and TTAdvance. I don't have link for a demo of ODIN. Can you provide one if you have?

 

[wasim_1ahmed]

Hi ,Can someone advice for beginer like me, from which broker icici direct,religare or india bulls should i open online account.Just for parttime shares trading.Thank you.

 

[Satish_CN]

what do you mean by deposit? will it be refunded or is it plan charges? I am thinking of switching broker too. Here is a thread you might find useful.

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/29178-differences-between-trader-terminals.html

I have pasted some links to PIB, TT and TTAdvance. I don't have link for a demo of ODIN. Can you provide one if you have?

Hi
The Rs 2500 is adjusted against the brokerage. That means that at 0.25% delivery brokerage, you will exhaust it with a Rs 10 lakh volume.
Sorry I do not have any link for ODIN. Am sure our more experienced members can help.

Regards,
S

 

[ktimptim]

Hi ,Can someone advice for beginer like me, from which broker icici direct,religare or india bulls should i open online account.Just for parttime shares trading.Thank you.

if you are in for part time, you can pick any one with your eyes closed. coz, they all sucks.. one way or another............

if you are seriously in to it, then you have to do lot of comparisons, and pick one according to your intended trading style.

adios!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[lazytrader]

Hi
The Rs 2500 is adjusted against the brokerage. That means that at 0.25% delivery brokerage, you will exhaust it with a Rs 10 lakh volume.
Sorry I do not have any link for ODIN. Am sure our more experienced members can help.

Regards,
S

Is the brokerage the same everywhere or did you bargain for lower brokerage? You also get charting with it right?

if you are in for part time, you can pick any one with your eyes closed. coz, they all sucks.. one way or another............

if you are seriously in to it, then you have to do lot of comparisons, and pick one according to your intended trading style.

adios!!!!!!!!!!!!

I pretty much agree with ktimptim

 

[pritam1232007]

i got suck with my broker motilal and indiabull their charge is too high .04% on both side plus tax total cost is .12% for intraday.. this is really high as compare to reliance money and share khan...

 

[Satish_CN]

Is the brokerage the same everywhere or did you bargain for lower brokerage? You also get charting with it right?



I pretty much agree with ktimptim

Hi again,
There are two different things; one is a trading account/ platform (web based or exe) - that is 999 per annum for one with charting and 499 for one without, and the other thing is the different brokerage plans you can link with these trading accounts, mainly depending on the amount of "advance brokerage" you will deposit with them.

http://www.religareonline.com/to_fees.asp (right click the given choices and open in different windows/ tabs)

http://www.religareonline.com/to_platform.asp

http://www.religareonline.com/trumpact.html

http://www.religareonline.com/freedomact.html

Hope this helps, I'll be glad to assist with further queries / pass you further info - They are coming to meet me tomorrow.

Regards,
S

 

[wasim_1ahmed]

Hi,
Please elaborate what are the factors ,i will have to keep in mind to open an online account and if i be serious about it.Thanks for yours previous reply.