Search results

@Zerodha, You are being quite prompt in replying to other queries in this forum but you are comfortably avoiding replying to issue regarding freak trade in Minifty. Can we know the reason for this?... Is it because you r least concerned with genuine investor concerns? Or is ur conflict...

This is like a bomb is blast and many people get injured... and government just hides all the evidence of the blast and does nothing to heal the injured... so on wch side is the government then? In case of Minifty freak trade: on whose side is SEBI? P.S.: sorry if analogy is bad... but...

@Zerodha, You guys had promised me on phone that you have invited all those who suffered due to this freak trade to send a mail to you and you will forward a collective mail on our behalf to NSE. Can you please confirm publicly that you have done so... this might help us believe that you r...

@Zerodha, You ask us to accept that **** happens and move on.... Which means u expect us to believe that such things will happen again... in tht case just tell me who will ever feel safe in future to apply a stop loss. Also, why wdnt some entity with vested interests take advantage of...

Dreamer, Point of worry is not at what price order got executed.... point of worry is tht if it has happened once, it can happen again... point of worry is tht u were taken out of ur trade without ur choice....

Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss Dreamer, i had placed SL-L order. And execution took place as per the trigger and limit prices.. but prob is trigger was activated by this freak trade... else trigger wont hv got activated...

Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss Debit done as per the trades executed... all trades are reflecting in the contract note... no cancellation or reversal of orders :(

Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss @Soft Trader, Yes, i just now received contract note and margin statement from Zerodha conforming trade execution. i also get NSE document confirming every trade... waiting for tht email...

Dreamer, the trade was shown in some charts during mkt hrs... i hear from unconfirmed sources tht the freak trade was later cancelled by NSE and removed from EOD OHLC values. So if the freak trade was cancelled, then all the stop losses hit due to that trade shd also be cancelled.

Zerodha, please speak up... we are waiting to hear from you...

Absolutely Sach007... thats the lesson i have learnt today...

Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss Shridhar, Thx for coming out with your problem as well. @Zerodha, I would like Zerodha to take this matter very seriously on behalf of their clients and put pressure on NSE to avoid executing such freak trades. If these trades...

hi sach007, Thanx for ur support. Is there any way i can raise this issue with NSE

Re: Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss Hi linkon7, thanx for posting this conversation. It means really such a trade did happen. But in that case all those who were long at that time and had placed limit stop loss orders at some level or the other must have had their...

Zerodha: Freak Trade in Minifty Triggering Stop Loss A very freak incident happened today and i want to know if other traders in this forum using Zerodha faced the same thing: I would like readers to go thru this carefully and give their views... i also expect Zerodha to reply on this...

Wish you all the luck... :thumb:

Absolutely, Beduk"Ji" .. how did i commit such a fatal error :p Must be yet another beginner's mistake :lol:

@Beduk, Hope you don't mind if i post my experience here too. Tuesday was my 1st trading day. Traded 1 lot of Minifty twice. Since i didn't have futures charts, i relied on GF spot chart and added the premium to it. Trade 1: Shorted @5326.70. SL hit @5350 :( Trade 2...

I too use Google Finance from Chrome... with an Indian account.... with candlesticks as my default view... It shows 2 min, 5 min, 30 min, daily and weekly charts .... i guess it must be same with your US account... not sure though... It does not show other time frames like 1 min or 15 min...

You r welcome Bedukji. Yeah, it would have been better if we could choose our preferred time frame on Google Finance.... and if we could draw trendlines... and save them... Guess i am being too greedy :D